12 Tips for Handling Toxic Forum Members
Forum Articles

12 Tips for Handling Toxic Forum Members

Shawn Gossman · · 8 min read · 94 views

The last thing you want to deal with in your Forum Spark community is toxic forum members.

These members not only disrupt the normal vibes of the community, but they can also ruin the community. If you don’t deal with them quickly, they can create a mutiny on the forum and cause people to take sides.

I’ve seen large forums fall and have to close down because just one toxic member got away with their abuse for too long.

In this guide, I’ll show you how to deal with toxic forum members the right way so that your forum doesn’t get ruined in the process.

1: Establish Clear Community Guidelines

The first step in dealing with toxic forum members is to set clear community guidelines on your forum.

Most every forum out there has some kind of rules, and they are usually common sense. No abuse, spam, illegal activity, privacy violations, and stuff like that is all you really need. You just need to make sure you have a policy published, and it is easy to find so that members understand what they can and cannot do on your forum.

If you have to take action against a problem member, you’ll have active guidelines to back up your reasoning for taking action against them.

2: Difference Between Disagreement and Toxicity

Before you jump to conclusions and cause a bigger problem than what exists, you need to understand the difference between disagreements and toxic forum members.

Unpopular opinions and differences of opinion don’t mean members are being toxic. If members are treating each other with respect, but they don’t agree with one another, then there really isn’t a problem for the time being. It’s when members start disrespecting one another over a disagreement that it becomes a problem.

Try to intervene and calm the situation, reminding everyone to respect each other’s opinions if things start to get intense.

3: Address Problems Before They Escalate

Before a problem becomes a bigger problem, you need to jump into action and take care of the situation.

If disagreeing members start to get passively aggressive or make small insults, then it’s time to step in. Remind the community of your rules and be firm about not allowing toxic activity on your forum. People are looking to you to lead and take control of the situation as quickly as possible.

This is often the moment that makes or breaks toxic forum members from being able to create havoc on the forum.

4: Handle Individual Problems Privately

If applicable, try to handle problem members in private to minimize public incidents from occurring.

If you see a few members getting toxic with one another, send them each a message about it. Talk to each one-on-one through the private message system. Explain the rules and discuss how the issue can be resolved without escalating it to abuse.

Dealing with problem members in front of the whole community can be embarrassing and only create further anger because of it.

5: Never Argue with Toxic Forum Members

Toxic forum members and trolls typically want you to argue with them because it makes you look bad in front of your community.

Don’t give these people the satisfaction of arguing with them. Send them a message in private with a link to the rules and firmly tell them what you expect from them. Remind them that they do not have to keep using the forum if they disagree with how you moderate it and what rules you have set.

An argument will never end in success; instead, it will likely end with more members getting involved because it became toxic.

6: Use a Progressive Discipline System

Don’t just ban a member every time they do anything wrong on your forum.

Use a progressive moderation system to deal with toxic forum members. Issue warnings, temporary suspensions, feature restrictions, and different types of bans. Allow problem members the chance to behave so that moderation actions can eventually expire or be removed.

You should definitely do a thorough investigation before taking action to make sure the action you take is actually justified.

7: Don’t Give Other Members Special Treatment

The best way to turn a forum into a toxic environment is to give other members special treatment over the rest of the community.

It’s okay to award your first active members or have a premium membership group. It’s not okay to let status members form and allow certain groups and members to break the rules while enforcing them on other members and groups. The rules should be made for all members, staff, and even you to follow accordingly.

No one on your forum should get special treatment when it comes to abiding by the rules and being disciplined for violating them.

8: Keep Records of Repeated Violations

Create some staff-only sections to keep a record of toxic forum members and their violating content.

I created two sections on my forum – staff discussions and post storage. Staff discussions is where forum staff talk about problem members and moderation actions, and post storage is where violating content is moved to be saved out of public view. You should always keep a record of problem members and their violating content on your forum.

This will create a record for other staff members, and especially new staff members, to be able to see members who have frequent issues.

9: Don’t Give Toxic Forum Members Any Control

Toxic forum members should never be allowed to gain control of a situation on the forum.

If a member derails a conversation and it becomes toxic, then you should take control of the situation and require members to get back on topic, and the toxicity be halted at once. Remove any personal attacks, redirect problematic conversations, and close topics if they need to be closed. The last thing you want is a problem member doing whatever they wish on a problem topic.

Allowing a member control of a topic is only going to result in making things worse, and it will be harder to deal with problems.

10: Encourage Members to Report Things

Provide ways for members to report violations when they see them so that you can handle them at a quicker pace.

Tell your members to report things that look suspicious even if it turns out to not be a problem. Members shouldn’t fear reporting the wrong things unless they’re knowingly abusing the reporting system. Make sure abuse reports stay private so that no further toxicity occurs between the problem member and the reporting party.

The faster you get word of a problem, the easier it will be to stop it from getting out of control.

11: Give Problem Members a Chance to Improve

Sometimes toxic forum members can improve and become good standing members of the community.

Most of the time, problem members are banned and never get a chance to improve. Try to be better by giving them a chance to turn their behavior around and become a better forum member. Give people a chance when they deserve to have another chance, but don’t let them take advantage of you in the process.

Who knows, you might be able to turn a bad member into a good member and prevent a lot of abuse all over the forum community.

12: Know When it’s Time to Ban Toxic Forum Members

When all else fails, you might have to permanently ban a forum member for being abusive, and that is what has to be done.

Not all toxic forum members can be stopped. Sometimes you have to issue a full ban to enforce your rules and set an example of what is not tolerated on your forum. For extreme abuse, racism, criminal activity, or repeated violations, a lifetime ban for your forum may be warranted.

You can always create an appeal system and let some banned members appeal their ban for further investigation.

Final Thoughts About Toxic Forum Members

I hope you have found this article about dealing with toxic forum members to be helpful for your community administration needs.

The biggest trick here is to stop the abuse before it gets out of hand. If you don’t intervene quickly, it might ruin your forum altogether. As I stated above, I’ve seen huge forums fall and close because one toxic member was allowed to get out of hand and turn the community against one another.

If you don’t have your own forum yet, create one on Forum Spark today, and we’ll help you get the most out of being a community leader.

Board Statistics
324
Posts
88
Topics
11
Members
13 online now · 1 today record 551 · newest member ashley

Users Online

13 users online in the last 30 minutes (0 members · 13 guests)

There's no-one here. Login or Register